Greatest League One playoff finals ever

Sports Mole takes a look at the greatest League One playoff finals.

The League One playoffs carry a pressure like no other, particularly the final where dreams of promotion to the second tier are either realised or crushed in just one match under the famous arch of Wembley Stadium.

Since they were introduced back in 1987, the EFL playoffs have delivered some of the most enthralling, drama-filled matches filled with last-minute winners, penalty shootouts and stunning strikes over the years.

With that in mind, Sports Mole takes a look at the top three greatest ever League One playoff finals.


3. Millwall 2-3 Scunthorpe United - 2009 League One playoff final

Fifteen years ago, Scunthorpe came out on top in a five-goal thriller against Millwall to secure promotion back to the Championship at the first attempt under the tutelage of manager Nigel Adkins.

After squeezing into the playoffs with a sixth-placed finish in League One, the Iron edged past MK Dons via a penalty shootout to progress to their second Wembley final of the season, just over a month after losing the EFL trophy final to Luton Town.

Millwall, meanwhile, beat Leeds United over two legs in the semi-finals and then found themselves 2-1 ahead in the playoff final heading into half time, with a quickfire brace from Gary Alexander - including a spectacular 35-yard volley - turning the game on its head after Scunthorpe legend Matt Sparrow had scored a sixth-minute opener.

However, Scunthorpe picked themselves off the canvas and valiantly fought their way back into the contest, with Sparrow slotting home a composed finish to restore parity in the 70th minute before Martyn Woolford scored a dramatic winner five minutes from time with a low-driven shot into the bottom corner, not long after Alexander missed a glorious chance at the other end from just six yards out to complete his hat-trick.

Both teams have since experienced mixed fortunes in league football, with Millwall having just completed their seventh successive season in the Championship, while Scunthorpe are now competing in the National League North (the sixth tier of English football).


2. Rotherham United 2-2 Leyton Orient (Rotherham win 4-3 on penalties) - 2014 League One playoff final

Rotherham were the comeback kings of the 2013-14 campaign as they came from behind in both the playoff semi-finals and final to secure back-to-back promotions and return to the Championship.

After overturning a one-goal deficit to beat Preston North End on aggregate in the semi-finals, the Millers were trailing by two goals at half time against Orient in the final, courtesy of a brilliant 25-yard opener from Moses Odubajo and a simple tap-in from Dean Cox.

However, Steve Evans's half-time team talk did the trick, as his Rotherham side were back on level terms by the hour mark thanks to a quickfire brace from Alex Revell, who stabbed home his first from close range before equalising just five minutes later with a looping 30-yard half-volley over Orient goalkeeper Jamie Jones.

Neither side could be separated after 120 minutes of engrossing playoff action, but the momentum soon swung back in the favour of Orient during the penalty shootout as they held a 3-2 advantage thanks to Jones saving Lee Frecklington's spot kick.

However, Rotherham prevailed as James Tavernier - now strutting his stuff as Rangers captain - and Richard Smallwood both converted from 12 yards before Adam Collin made two crucial stops to keep out Mathieu Baudry and Chris Dagnall, securing a 4-3 shootout triumph and sending the Millers into the second tier in dramatic fashion.


1. Gillingham 2-2 Manchester City (Man City win 3-1 on penalties) - 1999 Division Two playoff final

Manchester City's memorable playoff triumph over Gillingham is regarded by many as the match that saved the club and one that ultimately paved the way for further success in years to come.

The Citizens hit their lowest ebb when they slumped to 12th place in the third tier at Christmas following an embarrassing defeat at York City, but Joe Royle's side eventually climbed up to third to secure a playoff spot - and the rest is history.

All four goals of the showpiece event were scored in the final ten minutes, with Man City staring down the barrel of defeat heading into stoppage time after Carl Asaba and Robert Taylor scored two late goals for Tony Pulis's Gillingham. However, Royle's men would not go down without a fight and they mounted the most dramatic of comebacks.

Kevin Horlock pulled one back for City with a 90th-minute strike, before Paul Dickov etched his name in the club's folklore when he smashed a 95th-minute equaliser into the top corner to spark bedlam in the Citizens section at Wembley.

Following a goalless 30 minutes of extra time, Man City goalkeeper Nicky Weaver became the hero with two crucial penalty saves, as Horlock, Terry Cooke and Richard Edghill all converted from 12 yards to give the Citizens a 3-1 shootout triumph and secure promotion back to the second tier.


Honourable mentions:


• Sheffield Wednesday 1-0 Barnsley (AET) - 2023
• Charlton Athletic 2-1 Sunderland - 2019
• Barnsley 2-2 Swansea City (Barnsley won 4-3 on penalties) - 2006
• Hartlepool United 2-4 Sheffield Wednesday - 2005
• Walsall 3-2 Reading (AET) - 2001

ID:543667:1false2false3false: from db desktop :LenBod:collect9514:
Written by
Oliver Thomas
Game History

How you voted: Bolton vs Oxford Utd

Bolton Wanderers
65.7%
Draw
4.6%
Oxford United
29.6%
108
Collect / Create New Data
Share this article now:
Arsenal manager Arsene Wenger in 2016.
Read Next:
Top 20 Premier League managers who have taken charge of the most games in history
>
Sports Mole Logo
Enter your email address to subscribe to Sports Mole's free daily transfer newsletter! Sent twice a day during the transfer window.
rhs 2.0
Tables header RHS
TeamPWDLFAGDPTS
CLiverpool38259486414584
2Arsenal382014469343574
3Manchester CityMan City38218972442871
4Chelsea38209964432169
5Newcastle UnitedNewcastle382061268472166
6Aston Villa38199105851766
7Nottingham ForestNott'm Forest381981158461265
8Brighton & Hove AlbionBrighton38161396659761
9Bournemouth3815111258461256
10Brentford38168146657956
11Fulham38159145454054
12Crystal Palace381314115151053
13Everton381115124244-248
14West Ham UnitedWest Ham381110174662-1643
15Manchester UnitedMan Utd38119184454-1042
16Wolverhampton WanderersWolves38126205469-1542
17Tottenham HotspurSpurs38115226465-138
RLeicester CityLeicester3867253380-4725
RIpswich TownIpswich38410243682-4622
RSouthampton3826302686-6012


Sports Mole provides in-depth previews and predictions for every match from the biggest leagues and competitions in world football.
Argentina's Lionel Messi kisses the World Cup trophy after collecting the Golden Ball award on December 18, 2022Sign up for our FREE daily preview newsletter direct to your inbox!